16 November 2026. Revised version of an article originally published on 23 January 2022.

In late 2021, I came across an image on Ancestry, uploaded by a Coningham family member, showing 1829 silhouette portraits of Robert Coningham, William Coningham, and a ‘James Coningham’. At first, I thought this James Coningham must be a relative of Robert and William, perhaps a cousin. Then I looked more closely. James Coningham appears to be holding a naval cap, and his profile resembles what a teenage James Fitzjames would have looked like… Eventually, I concluded that the James Coningham portrayed alongside Robert and William Coningham was actually James Fitzjames. In 2026, I was lucky enough to acquire the version of Fitzjames and William’s portrait that they would have seen on the wall of their family home. Let’s dive into the history behind these Coningham silhouette portraits.

© 2014 by Peggy McClard Americana & Folk Art

The artist
The Coningham silhouette portraits were made by Auguste Amant Constant Fidèle Edouart (1789–1861), a renowned French artist who later worked in the United Kingdom and the United States. The term silhouette derives from 18th-century French finance minister Étienne de Silhouette, who, with his austerity measures, caused poorly or cheaply made things to be called à la Silhouette. Cut-paper portraits were comparatively inexpensive and therefore à la Silhouette. (Edouart, 1835, p. 9) In the UK it was called by multiple names: (black) shade, (black) profile, likeness, scissartype…
Among Edouart’s famous clients were the French and English Royal Families and Sir Walter Scott. Edouart kept duplicates of all his work and carefully recorded the sitter’s name, location, and the date the portrait was taken. “A copy of every Likeness taken is kept by me, in books for the purpose; so that at any time, the person or friends may have as many duplicates as they require, and at a less price.” (Edouart, 1835, p. 23)

Advertisement from the Morning Post of 7 May 1829.

Unfortunately, a large portion of his catalogue was lost when, in 1849, Edouart’s ship was wrecked in a storm off Guernsey on his passage to England. One trunk, containing six of his American silhouettes and ten of his British ones, survived. Thankfully, the Coningham silhouettes were among them.
Edouart gave the surviving albums to the Lukis family in Guernsey, as a thank you for looking after him before he returned to France. In 1911, Emily Nevill Jackson (1861-1947), a British collector and author, was writing a book on the history of silhouette portraits and placed an ad in a magazine, asking for information on silhouette collections. A Lukis descendant decided to sell his family’s Edouart albums to Mrs. Jackson. (NYU Libraries)

The advantage of keeping duplicates
In his 1835 book, A Treatise on Silhouette Likenesses, Edouart shared that he did not merely keep duplicates of his portraits for the sake of being able to provide copies to his clients, but that he had the foresight that his records could benefit historical research:
“In the researches made after the incidents in the life of any individual, who may have enjoyed considerable renown, as a public man, there may arise difficulties as to dates and places, which involve, perhaps the most interesting moments of his life in obscurity, from which the copy I had taken of his likeness, would effectually rescue them, merely by reference to the date and place written upon every one of the copies, at the time the sitter was with me. Thus, to have the place in which an eminent individual might have resided at some particular period, would probably afford an elucidation in his Biographical Memoirs, of no contemptible importance.” (Edouart, 1835, p. 112)
And indeed, with no existing correspondence between Fitzjames and the Coninghams between October 1828 and December 1830 because he was living with them, their visit to the silhouette artist and the information that Robert Coningham probably introduced the boys as William & James Coningham and gave their abode as Watford, provides interesting insight. Not to mention the wonderful ability to see what they all looked like in 1829.

Edouart described his process of cataloguing thus: “To speak concerning my labours, I shall give an idea of them: the names of the persons I take, and the dates, written five times over — first, on the duplicate of the Likeness — secondly, in my day book – thirdly, in the book in which I preserve them — fourthly, in the index of that book and fifthly, in the general index. This much in itself is a hard task to fulfil. Without this arrangement, how could I, at a minute’s notice tell, whether I had taken the Likeness of any person enquired for, and could it be otherwise possible, to produce the Silhouette, or to know from about fifty books folio size, and above fifty thousand Likenesses, if I had taken the one required? For correctness’ sake, I have also a diary of what I do, and by that means, am able to tell the quantity of full lengths, are children, duplicates, public characters, busts, and animals, I have taken since I began. All this is done by myself, to avoid mistakes which may be made by others, detrimental to the accuracy requisite in a collection of the kind, where surnames and christian names ought to be exact to a letter.” (Edouart, 1835, pp. 98-99)

Identifying Fitzjames
The question is: how did James Fitzjames come to be called James Coningham by Edouart? Edouart was very meticulous in noting down the details of his clients and keeping up to date about their lives, even going back later to add ‘Died 22 May 1836’ under Robert’s portrait. Did Robert introduce the boys as William and James Coningham, not caring to explain their familial situation to the artist, whom they would spend very little time with and then never see again?

In her book Ancestors in silhouette cut by August Edouart (1921), Mrs. Jackson provides a list of the names of 8000 English, Scottish and Irish sitters and the date plus location their portrait was made. For the Coninghams, the following is registered:
“Coningham, Master James (London, Jan. 23, 1829)
Coningham, Master Wm. (London, Jan. 23., 1829)
Coningham, Mrs. (London, April 24, 1829)
Coningham, Rev. R., Watford, Herts, [Died] May 22 [1836] (London, Jan. 24, 1829)” (Jackson, 1921, pp. 125-126)
There is also a John Sterling who had his portrait done in London on 29 January 1829, who is probably Robert’s nephew. (Jackson, 1921, p. 167)

Mrs. Coningham was not Robert’s wife Louisa, but his mother Elizabeth. The page from Edouart’s catalogue with her portrait was most recently sold at auction house New Orleans Auction in 2018. When Elizabeth died, Edouart added “Died Janry 1837. 83 yrs of Age.”

Mrs. Coningham. Source: https://www.neworleansauction.com/auction-lot/auguste-edouart-french-active-u.k.-u.s.-1789_1B944388E9

Pose and personality
Edouart cut the silhouette portrait in a matter of minutes, using only his own observation, scissors and two pieces of black paper to create two copies at once. “The time I occupy in taking a Likeness, is generally five minutes, sometimes more and sometimes less, according to circumstances.” (Edouart, 1835, p. 91)

Here you can watch a video of how a modern silhouette artist creates his portraits and here is another interesting and very fun one about a silhouette artist in Disneyland.

On 23 January 1829, when they went to Edouart’s studio, William was 13.5 years old and Fitzjames 15.5 years old. William still looked like a boy, while Fitzjames was taller and already looking like quite the young gentleman. His hand-on-hip pose looks confident, and his gesture recalls the adlocutio pose typically shown by ancient Roman statues of emperors, signifying leadership and skill as an orator.

Edouart said that “the hand, by its motions, is very expressive; of all the parts of the body, the most active and the most rich in articulations: for this reason, I have taken care to produce a concordance between the gesture and the expression of the features […]. The hand speaks, and its conformation, with more than twenty joints, produces the articulation of the language. A straight finger according to the angle of position, will indicate command, threats, derision, demonstration, attention, & c . & c . & c.” (Edouart, 1835, pp. 20-21)

It was important to Edouart that the sitter’s unique features and personality were conveyed in their silhouette likeness, to such an extent that a relative or friend could instantly recognise the sitter. He strove to create living images, not statues. He also made sure that when placing his sitters together, he maintained their actual height difference. (Edouart, 1835, p. 36)

“Persons having their Likenesses, should be careful to stand in their natural attitude, and as easy as possible. […] The features must be allowed their natural freedom; frequently I enter into conversation with the sitter, on purpose to give him a speaking expression […]. For my own part, as I have only an outline to represent objects, I am very particular never to deviate from it; and I have very often refused to take Likenesses when the sitters pretending, some to have a few inches more in height, some not to be so corpulent, others to be erect when they had a stoop, and many other alterations, which would effectually spoil the Likeness.” (Edouart, 1835, pp. 17-18)

The full sheet
In October 2014, the sheet with the Coninghams and Cutler silhouettes came up for auction at Cowan’s and was bought and subsequently resold by McClard Segotta Antiques to a private collector. Many thanks to Peggy McClard for providing a clear picture of the silhouettes and some background information. The page is now in a private collection in America.

Besides the Coninghams, another person’s portrait appears on the same sheet. To the right of James Coningham, there is a silhouette of one Adolphus Cutler, Esquire. In Edouart’s list it says “Cutler, Adolphus, Esq., City (London, Feb. 23, 1829)”. [Jackson, p. 128] This man appears to be entirely unrelated to and unassociated with the Coninghams. On the other side of the sheet are portraits of Madame and Monsieur Duport and Mr. and Mrs. M.G. Dennis.

The customer’s version
But since the aforementioned sheet contained only the artist’s duplicates, the version of the portraits that the customer, the Coninghams, got had to be somewhere out there too! The descendants of William Coningham whom I visited did not have any silhouette portraits of their ancestors. So, I made an auction alert (I have MANY auction alerts) and faithfully checked every single one for four years, hoping to see the Coningham silhouettes one day. Lo and behold, on 26 September 2026, an alert came in for an Edouart portrait of “two gentlemen in conversation”. Even from the small image I saw in the email, I could immediately tell who they were. THAT’S FITZJAMES AND WILLIAM CONINGHAM!!

Thankfully, the auction house was unable to identify the subjects because their names were not written anywhere on the portrait. With help from Russell Potter and Douglas Wamsley, I won the auction, and the silhouette portrait of Fitzjames and William Coningham became mine.

Mrs. Jackson closes her book with the hope that “[Edouart’s] ghost Shadows may again be clothed in flesh and blood by those who recognise their Ancestors in Silhouette.” (Jackson, 1921, p. 107) This portrait of Fitzjames and William Coningham has hung on collectors’ walls without anyone knowing who these boys were. Now, their names and identities have been restored. This portrait once hung in the Coningham home, where Fitzjames would have seen it. How special is that!

William and Fitzjames on the beach

Detail of ‘Silhouette portrait of William Coningham and James Fitzjames’ by Augustin Edouart. 1829. Collection of Fabiënne Tetteroo.

What had puzzled me about William’s silhouette portrait was that he was holding what looks like a conch. Was that his special interest, an attribute people would recognise him by? Now that I have seen the end product that the Coninghams got, it all makes sense.
The watercolour background shows Fitzjames and William on a beach, with cliffs behind them. They are discussing the conch that William is holding, which he probably just found. Unfortunately, the watercolour background appears to have been damaged in the upper part of the portrait. All that is now visible are the pencil outlines. There is a building with two towers at the top of the cliffs. This is possibly the ruins of St Mary’s Church in Reculver. I had originally identified Fitzjames by the cap he was holding, which looked like a naval cap. But in the customer’s version, William also has a cap, which is lying on the ground.
I will do more research into where Fitzjames and William are depicted and why the Coninghams wanted this memorialised. I will present my findings in my book.

Left: silhouette portrait of James Fitzjames by Augustin Edouart. 1829. Collection of Fabiënne Tetteroo. Right: daguerreotype of James Fitzjames by Richard Beard. 1845. Sold by Sotheby’s in 2023.
Left: photo of William Coningham by Anthony Coningham Sterling. 1853. National Portrait Gallery. NPG P171(41). Right: silhouette portrait of William Coningham by Augustin Edouart. 1829. Collection of Fabiënne Tetteroo.

Bibliography
Edouart, Augustin Amant Constant Fidèle A Treatise on Silhouette Likenesses 1835
Jackson, Mrs. F. Nevill The history of silhouettes, 1911.
Jackson, Mrs. F. Nevill Ancestors in silhouette cut by August Edouart, 1921

Online:

https://findingaids.library.nyu.edu/nyhs/pr101_jackson_edouart/ NYU Libraries.